Volume:5, Issue: 1/2

May. 1, 2013

Comparative analysis of debates over History Education in Western European Nations: From the Passionate to the Smooth
Boyer, Eric S. [about]

DESCRIPTORS:  History Education, History as a Discipline, Passionate vs. Smooth Debates, Historical Thinking, Historical Interpretation, Critical Thinking, Habits of Mind, Globalization, Internet.

SYNOPSIS: Debates about History education have traditionally been passionate, concerning national pride or patriotic indoctrination.  Recently however, much smoother debates about how the discipline can be used as a way to mold critical thinking skills and the abilities of academic analysis have emerged.  Interestingly, the course of history has produced new ways of approaching the discipline of history in schooling in Western European Nations, specifically with the advent of the Internet.  Here, I seek to identify a shift in the uses of history education in western European nations, describe these uses as part of the shared western heritage of these countries, and identify how the modern context of globalization assists in molding this marked shift towards more democratic and liberal minded citizens. 


Theories: Why Teach History?

The Roman Historian Titus Livius Patavinus (Livy) lays out a very general notion of what it means to study History.  Simply put, History is a template of human activity that future generations can utilize to examine and draw upon to make decisions for present societal situations.  Within his statement is inherent the notion of the supreme interconnectedness of the personal and the public:

“The study of history is the best medicine for a sick mind; for in history you have a record of the infinite variety of human experience plainly set out for all to see: and in that record you can find for yourself and your country both examples and warnings: fine things to take as models, base things, rotten through and through, to avoid” (Livy, Chapter XLIII (43)). 

Taking in the grand sweep of history it is apparent that one of the fundamental goals inherent in teaching history to younger generations is to produce good citizens, both within the private as well as the public sphere, as a good citizen in the home will presumably be well translated to be a good citizen outside the home.  Great thinkers throughout time have continually espoused this notion of history and its inherent connection to teaching youth the importance of living and working within the human sphere.  In short, an investigation of the multifaceted ways humans interact over time provides youth an opportunity to examine their own personal sphere and their personal behavior. The Renaissance political philosopher Machiavelli once said:

Whoever wishes to foresee the future must consult the past; for human events ever resemble those of preceding times. This arises from the fact that they are produced by men who ever have been, and ever shall be, animated by the same passions, and thus they necessarily have the same results.” (Machiavelli, p. 43)

Machiavelli writing in the 16th Century echoes Livy writing in the 1st Century.

These statements taken together are echoed by the Enlightenment thinker and original American statesman Thomas Jefferson writing in the late 18th Century: 

Schooling in America should be chiefly historical." The people are the ultimate guardians of their own liberty. History, by apprising them of the past, will enable them to judge of the future. It will avail them of the experience of other times and other nations; it will qualify them as judges of the actions and designs of men." (Jefferson, p. 271).  

A century and a half later another American President, working with the Committee of Ten, Woodrow Wilson agreed that: “History and its allied branches are better adapted than any other studies to promote the invaluable mental power, which we call judgment." (Mitchell, 1981)

It is clear then, that in the Western tradition many of our great leaders and thinkers believed that a democratic-republican form of political organization has a special need for an education of history, because this type of government involves the people. The people must acquire "democratic virtues" and learn through instructive examples from history respect for the rights of individuals, regard for the law, voluntary participation in public life, and concern for the common good.  In this tradition, we see time and again the notion that good history education is for the purpose of developing critical thinking, inquisitive, active participants within the “at present” community of human beings.  “History” here defined really becomes the collective knowledge of how and why people have behaved certain ways, and how this human interaction has influenced further social interaction within certain cultures and regions of the world.  Taken as a base, this notion of historical teaching connects to our modern day understanding of what it means to teach “critical thinking.”

Smooth vs. Passionate Debates Defined

Historical thinking within the discipline of history as a way to teach critical thinking as just described, is however a product of the “western” tradition.  That is, born of the political, economic and social organizations of the histories of England and France as well as their colonial offshoots, the Unites States and Canada respectively.  Determined to free students and subsequently western society from the narrow focus of a single authoritative historical narrative, historians practicing the discipline in the west claim that history is “important because it cannot tell a single approved story.  And this way of doing history opens up the possibility of more serious thought about what history education is and ought to be” (Lee, p. xii).  Namely, the fact that history education requires multiple perspectives, and in teaching students how to approach these perspectives from different angles utilizing various sources to debate the narrative, the skill of analyzing information critically (critical thinking) is nurtured and expanded. 

Examining current debates over history education within western European nations reveals that the core argument has become the how of implementing history as a discipline into the high school curriculum, as opposed to what (in terms of static information) should be included.  How to go about enriching the practices of the history discipline so as to be accessible to the high school (secondary) student is the primary focus of debate, and as such this debate is termed by Lee (2010) as “smooth.”  The “smoothness” implies a shared vision for history education as helping students build a historical framework about the past, enabling them to handle the present (and future) in historical terms, and “embracing a flexible knowledge of history coupled with a constant use of critical thinking skills and competences” (Lee, p. 2).   

Lee (2010) maintains that history education justifies itself by “providing a form of social cement.  This social glue may be thought to arise from its power to bind people to shared values through a particular national, regional, ethnic, political, or religious story” (Lee, p. xi).  The key word in Peter Lee’s (2010) statement is “values.”  And it is with this word I frame the difference between and the movement from, the passionate to the smooth.  The contention here is that countries of the western-European tradition have an evolving notion of the “values” inherent in modern history education. And this emerging value system has been formed by the recent historical forces of globalization.  As western-European nations increasingly identify a shared heritage in terms of political, economic and social arrangements, the need to distinguish themselves along nationalistic lines, inculcating passionate debates over national identity, have been lessened. 

If the value of history education in the west is of enhancing critical thought and an ability to analyze information, there is a marked difference in many non-western countries that centers on the value of maintaining (or sometimes re-creating) an approved story of the past.  Here Lee (2010) terms the debate as “passionate” because history education is conceived as “immediately relating to national history, national memory and identity” (Lee, p. 3).  A quick examination of debates in non-western nations reveals that any historical or educational idea, proposal or state attempt to reform history education (at least in concordance with the newly emerged western model), elicits passionate reactions from the public.  The conceptualization of history education is its use as a means to maintain and further cultivate national identity, not to ask questions about the past but to learn it and maintain it as the roots of the very specific contextual and cultural model.  This maintenance of passionate debates in non-western European nations can be seen explicitly in a group of papers published by the International Review of History Education (ed. Nakou & Barca, 2010) over the role of textbooks as tools for continued political/national narrative and identity construction.  Section III of this volume is titled “Passionate debates over the national past rather than over history education, mainly in political and national terms” (Nakou & Barca, p. viii).  The seven nations represented in this section lie outside the western-European tradition and range geographically from the Middle East, to Asia and Eastern Europe.  Identifying the specific debates within these countries, and the analysis provided by the authors of these papers is beyond the scope of the present work.  However, the overall trend in debates over history education in these nations is made plain by the title of the section.  And the purpose in mentioning them is to bolster the notion that a continued passionate national identity debate seems to continue in countries outside the western-European tradition, whereas the debates within the western-European tradition are distinctly moving away from this.         

Western European Nations: The Smooth Debates

The western tradition, built on a foundation of creating a good democratic citizen who is well informed, critical in thought, and decisive based on rational argument and analysis of perspective has effectively culminated in a crucial understanding of history education.  Thus, the debate about what should be included in the history curriculum in western European nations has given way in the last decade to a conversation about how history education should be taught.  Examining papers published in the last few years by history educators and reformers within western European nations reveals a common conversation about history education within as well as across these countries.  At its core, the renewed focus of history education is on “doing the discipline.”  That is, teaching students how to learn and understand history through the skills, concepts and knowledge historians use while interacting with the discipline itself.  Instead of reading, reciting and rewording the work historians have already laid out for students in a stale, static textbook, the goals of “doing the discipline” immerse the student into the world of the historian.  This world is one where the historian analyzes sources, critically thinks about differing or combative perspectives, forms an argument and actively debates and defends this argument.  A snapshot of statements from educators of history in these countries affirms the overarching goal of utilizing history as a discipline to teach students how to do history as a process, as opposed to how to learn history as a collection of facts. 

Peter Seixas (2010) opens his paper on modern changes in Canadian history education with this statement: “Since early 2006, a Canadian partnership between a university-based research center and a private, nonprofit foundation has promoted the development of historical thinking as a foundational element of history curriculum, pedagogy and assessment” (Seixas, p. 11).  He then goes on to trace the conceptualization, reception of, and prospects for introducing this development of history education and concludes that the only debate within this focus rests on the ways in which this type of education should be introduced, maintained and cultivated.  The contention by Seixas is that despite the very “smooth” debates within the aforementioned partnership for promoting historical thinking in the secondary classroom, the overall consensus was that this type of education “shifts the problem of what to include in the curriculum to an examination of how to handle the different and sometimes conflicting stories of the past” (Seixas, p. 20).  This analysis of recent changes in Canadian history curriculum mirror those of other western European nations.

Ashby and Edwards (2010) discuss the challenges faced in implementing a sound history education curriculum in an increasingly multicultural England.  Great Britain, having enjoyed a glorious past of control, domination and imperialism is often times loathe to rescind the greatness of its “Pax Britannica”.  A Conservative Party politician, Michael Gove, in a 2008 speech to his party stated, “history curriculum makes it possible for children to take pride in our past, the best way we can build Britishness is by making every child aware of the great things we as Britons have achieved” (Gove, para. 9). 

Recognizing this sort of one-sided thinking as antithetical to more modern notions of history education, Ashby and Edwards (2010) maintain that Gove’s statement represents one of the key challenges facing school history today, and contributes to the more “passionate” debates still existing outside modernized nations.  In response to Gove’s statement, Ashby and Edwards (2010) see this type of thinking as counterproductive, and inconsistent with the idea of history education as part and parcel of an open society.  The wider movement in history education within England in the last decade has been a “disciplinary approach to knowledge coupled with an understanding of the importance of this approach for history in an open society” (Ashby & Edwards, p. 29).  Outlining this disciplinary approach, Ashby and Edwards (2010) offer five descriptions of what students should encounter in the history classroom:  “Claims based on evidence, historical questions raised through relative influence, historical hypotheses developed through an examination of sources, an understanding of abstract concepts such as change, continuity and significance, and a conceptualization of the nature of interpretation” (Ashby & Edwards, p. 29).  These identified student outcomes can be viewed as essential components of absorbing and interpreting historical knowledge, and in creating judgments about the inherent value of knowledge.  These five “encounters” represent the move towards an education in history as opposed to indoctrination into the simplistic picture of Britain’s “glorious past” as presented by Gove (2008). 

France is one of the four main western European nations forming the group known as the “Group of Eight” (G8), in which the wealthiest countries in the world participate.  Its historical roots as an initiator of the implementation of enlightenment principles and a democratic-republican form of political organization set France on an early course of educational “excellence” that we now see as the traditional model of schooling around the world.  With this modern and historical context, globalization has placed France (as well as the other “7” of the G8) in a position to continue as a leader in providing equality of opportunity, especially with regard to education.  To ensure “equality,” however, can often come at the expense of “excellence,” meaning ability to constantly and consistently charter a course towards ever-improving student achievement across all populations represented.  As a way to combat this, France has evolved toward less authoritarian pedagogical practices, relying less on memorization and more on the development of critical thinking.  Standardized tests in France do not include multiple-choice questions and focus for evaluation has been on the utilization of written essays.  French pedagogues believe that “the essay approach provides more information on effective capacities and competences of students (quality of expression, capacity of structuring ideas, and so on) than multiple-choice tests” (Orivel & Orivel, p. 217).  In addition, France has adopted the theory of individualization of the learning process. Individualization presented here is taken as a base for the “acknowledgement of the learning process as one inextricable from analysis of multiple sources and perspectives” (Orivel & Orivel, p. 215). 

Turning to the United States, one of the most influential and powerful entities born out of the western European tradition, Peter Stearns (2010) articulates current debate over history education and leads his discussion with an important statement about a transition in America from the ‘passionate’ to the ‘smooth’:

“Passionate divisions in history education have declined during the past decade.  Key issues today involve ongoing discussions of whether and how to do world history, instead of Western civilization, and how to link other elements of the history curriculum to develop assessment and increasing interest in identifying key analytical skills over coverage concerns” (Stearns, p. 47).    

Essential ‘smooth’ debates Stearns identifies in the U.S. are those over teacher-training in the discipline of history, the issue of levels of content coverage versus ‘habits of mind’ in teaching history, and how to effectively and legitimately assess student understanding.  With regard to teacher training, Stearns (2010) notes that high school history teachers have “little or no training in the discipline,” and that the history they end up teaching “differs considerably from the work they had in college” (p. 50).  This becomes an issue if the goal for history education is to move away from the static textbook-based recitation of facts to a more engaged analysis of those facts, and how to mold and shape an understanding of history as a more dynamic, more fluid subject.  An active discussion has ensued between secondary school districts, teacher-training programs, and professional historians to identify, encourage and guide future history teachers towards a model history curriculum reflective of that fluidity.  If we expect critical thought to be a hallmark of history education, teachers must be given the tools of the historian alongside the tools of the teacher.  Here, once again, these discussions are increasingly focused on the how of history engagement as opposed to the what.     

What are those tools of the historian that a teacher needs?  This question connects to the second smooth debate cited above about content coverage versus ‘habits of mind’.  As most secondary history teachers are forced to cover an immense amount of information within a relatively small time period, the curriculum becomes fact drills and student outcomes become simple fact recitation.  Over the last decade groups of historians and teachers have recognized this entrenched form of education, and have been increasingly vocal about the essence of history learning.  These voices maintain “history learning is not memorization of names and dates, but a set of habits of mind that can be uniquely cultivated through training in historical analysis” (Stearns, p. 56).  These habits of mind are of course a cause for debate, but most historians and teachers have been able to agree on certain essentials to form a tentative list. 

The first would be the meat of what historians actually do, interpreting primary sources, analyzing the points of view in those sources and building arguments about the people, places and events presented.  Second would be to gain experience in dealing with conflicting interpretations, and being prepared to either defend or alter one’s own arguments.  And finally, Stearns (2006) cites, “experience in analyzing change over time, analysis of causation, and ability to identify continuities amid change” (Stearns, The impacts of history learning research) as quintessential to historical skills, and as most distinctively attached to the discipline. 

 Conclusions

Debate certainly continues over whether or not these habits of mind should in fact replace the more conventional (and seemingly easier) focus on the memorization of facts.  However, an immensely important development in the modern, increasingly globalized world has worked to declare that traditional history education model of fact recitation as almost null and void, namely the advent of the Internet.  Access to information via the web is now limitless, and the ability of the student to search established historical narratives in an instant demolishes the need for a teacher to simply recite information, or what might traditionally be referred to as lecture. 

Globalization coupled with a worldwide Internet culture is the latest development in the course of history to alter the way history is understood and taught.  It is now much less the role of the teacher to deliver historical information, and more the job of the teacher to facilitate student understanding, analysis, interpretation and synthesis of this information.  All of these facilitated capacities connect to the work of actual historians.  And each of these capacities can be seen as essential to the values inherent in the western tradition, creating a good democratic citizen who is a critical thinker in terms of information received, and decisive based on rational analysis of perspective.  

The four western European nations analyzed above have described these capacities of the student as essential to the furthering of a sound historical education.  Thus, the connection between historical thinking, critical thinking, and what it means to be an effective citizen in the globalized world, has effectively culminated in a crucial understanding of the future direction of history education.  What remains in this future is how exactly to go about making sure that teachers of history in the secondary schools worldwide receive training in historical thinking and the requisite skills that go along with this type of curriculum.  It is the hope here that these debates will continue to be “smooth,” and that the training of teachers, and subsequently, students in ‘habits of mind’ will be able to move forward in producing the types of citizens a democratic world needs to see develop.    

Ultimately, the ferocity and passion of earlier divisions of substantive (or nationalistic) history debates in western European nations (and still existing in non-western countries) can be ameliorated by the recognition that students be enabled through the school curriculum to participate thoughtfully in those debates.  Recognizing that providing the tools of the historian to both the teacher as facilitator of information, and the student as a learner of skills and ‘habits of mind’ rather than facts, effectively “soothes” the debate inherent in history education, and taken a step further, places history in the school curriculum as an essential course of study.  Thus, an understanding of the nature of historical interpretation and the use of evidence (i.e. being able to think historically) will inevitably provide a valuable starting point for moving forward with a much more democratic and liberally minded history education, and in turn, a much more democratic and liberally minded citizen.      

References:

  • Ashby, R. & Edwards, C. (2010). Challenges Facing the Disciplinary Tradition:  Reflections on the History Curriculum in England. Contemporary Public Debates Over History Education, Chapter 3, pp. 27-45.  Information Age Publishing. Charlotte, N.C.
  • Books of Titus Livius.'  Chapter XLIII (43)  Retrieved from:  http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/445270-the-study-of-history-is-the-best-medicine-for-a
  • Gove, M. (2008). Freeing schools to help the most disadvantaged.  Retrieved from http://www.conservatives.com/News/Speeches/2008/09/Michael_Gove_Freeing_good_schools_to_help_the_most_disadvantaged.aspx
  • Jefferson, Thomas. (1785). "Notes on the State of Virginia". pp. 271–275.  Retrieved from: http://etext.virginia.edu/toc/modeng/public/JefVirg.html
  • Lee, P. (2010). Series Introduction:  International Review of History Education. Contemporary Public Debates Over History Education, pp. xi-xvi/1-8.  Information Age Publishing. Charlotte, N.C.
  • Machiavelli, Niccolo. (1513). 'Natives of the Same Country Preserve for all Time the same Characteristics' in the Third Book of his 1513 work 'Discourses on the First Ten
  • Mitchell, Richard. (1981). The Graves of Academe. Boston: Little, Brown & Company
  • Nakou, I, & Barca, I, eds. (2010). Contemporary Public Debates over History Education.  A volume in International Review of Education.  Information Age Publishing. Charlotte N.C.
  • Orivel, E. & Orivel, F. (2006). French Education’s Dilemma in the Globalization Process:  How to Accommodate Simultaneously the Objectives of Equality and Excellence? Schooling Around the World: Debates, Challenges and Practices, Chapter 10, pp. 207-228.  Pearson Publishing, New York, NY. 
  • Seixas, P. (2010). A Modest Proposal for Change in Canadian History. Contemporary Public Debates Over History Education, Chapter 2, pp. 11-25.  Information Age Publishing. Charlotte, N.C.
  • Stearns, P.N. (2006, June).  The impacts of history learning research:  Achievements, gaps and implications.  Paper presented at the National History Center Conference, Washington, DC.  Retrieved from http://nationalhistorycenter.org/wpcontent/uploads/2008/04/stearnsbriefingpaper.pdf
  • Stearns, P.N. (2010).  History Debates:  The United States. Contemporary Public Debates Over History Education, Chapter 4, pp. 47-60.  Information Age Publishing. Charlotte, N.C.




peter (Dec. 05, 2017)
I can see that you are a specialist at your field! I am dispatching a site soon, and your data will be exceptionally helpful for me.. A debt of gratitude is in order for all your help and wishing all of you the achievement in your business. http://www.fiftymotion.com/best-wireless-routers-reviews/
chenjinyan (Dec. 04, 2017)

true religion jeans

canada goose outlet

jordans

replica watches

coach outlet

ferragamo shoes

air max

jordan shoes

nike football boots

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet

nike outlet

supra shoes

nike jordans

the north face

jordan shoes

north face uk

north face jackets clearance

ugg slippers

cheap ugg boots

uggs outlet

ralph lauren outlet stores

coach outlet

ugg boots

adidas originals uk

prada bags

air max

burberry outlet canada

coach outlet online

jordans

birkenstock uk

canada goose jackets

mbt shoes

polo ralph

north face

michael kors outlet

nike air max

true religion jeans

scarpe hogan

cheap oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet

canada goose outlet store

louboutin

flops

coach factory outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

mont blanc pens

chicago blackhawks jersey

longchamp handbags

ugg boots cheap

air max

oakley sunglasses cheap

coach outlet

ugg boots

canada goose outlet

oakley sunglasses

hollister clothing

salvatore ferragamo

tory burch outlet

coach outlet online

uggs outlet

true religion jeans

air max

north face outlet

longchamp

moncler

canada goose jackets

jordan retro

kate spade outlet

balance shoes

the north face

moncler outlet

ugg outlet

air jordan

coach outlet online

adidas football boots

north face jackets

uggs outlet

moncler pas cher

air jordan

ugg boots

uggs

michael kors handbags

ray ban

ugg

ugg outlet online

kate spade handbags

ralph lauren

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet online

north face jackets

moncler

swarovski

cheap ray bans

louboutin

michael kors handbags

mont blanc pens

ugg

kate spade

moncler jackets

201712.4chenjinyan
Robinjack (Dec. 03, 2017)
A debt of gratitude is in order for giving late reports with respect to the worry, I anticipate read more. Miami Auto Equity Loans
kakakaoo (Nov. 30, 2017)

polo ralph lauren outlet

ugg boots

jerseys cheap

hermens

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet online

longchamps

pandora jewelry store

ralph lauren

kate spade handbags

hermes bags

moncler jackets

adidas outlet store

nmd adidas

uggs on sale

cheap jordan shoes

nike outlet store online

pandora uk

louis vuitton outlet store

nike sneakers

polo ralph lauren outlet

christian louboutin sale

ugg outlet store

nike air max 2018

burberry outlet online

uggs clearance

cheap air jordans

adidas superstars

ugg boots clearance

pandora charms

moncler pas cher

tory burch shoes

canada goose sale

adidas nmd runner

canada goose outlet

adidas nmd r1

supreme clothing

adidas ultra boost

cheap ugg boots

adidas outlet online

michael kors handbags

ugg outlet online

salvatore ferragamo shoes

longchamp bags

uggs outlet

ugg sale

cheap jordan shoes

ralph lauren outlet online

canada goose jackets

ugg boots outlet

tory burch outlet online

coach outlet online

longchamp bags

oakley sunglasses outlet

ralph lauren sale

canada goose coats

adidas shoes

ralph lauren sale

ralph lauren sale clearance uk

pandora charms outlet

canada goose coats

canada goose

ugg outlet store

louboutin outlet

louis vuitton outlet

uggs outlet online

coach outlet canada

coach outlet store online

canada goose outlet

christian louboutin shoes

adidas nmd r1

gucci outlet online

adidas yeezy boost

burberry outlet

michael kors outlet store

ugg australia outlet

ugg boots

moncler outlet online

coach factory outlet online

ralph lauren uk

louis vuitton factory outlet

oakley sunglasses outlet

louboutin shoes

canada goose outlet store

pandora outlet

canada goose parka

ugg boots

coach purses

ralph lauren sale

valentino outlet

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet clearance

bottes ugg

ugg canada

moncler

michael kors outlet online

mlb jerseys whgolesale

adidas outlet store

uggs outlet

171130yueqin

Robinjack (Nov. 26, 2017)
Really a great addition. I have read this marvelous post. Thanks for sharing information about it. I really like that. Thanks so lot for your convene. florida pr agencies
peter (Nov. 25, 2017)
Situs QQRaja.com merupakan situs poker online terpercaya yang memberikan berbagai macam game seperti Ceme Online uang asli terbesar dan terpercaya di Indonesia. poker online Indonesia
peter (Nov. 25, 2017)
I can see that you are a specialist at your field! I am dispatching a site soon, and your data will be exceptionally helpful for me.. A debt of gratitude is in order for all your help and wishing all of you the achievement in your business. www.twentymotion.com/best-hair-rollers-reviews/
Robinjack (Nov. 25, 2017)
A debt of gratitude is in order for a superb offer. Your article has demonstrated your diligent work and experience you have in this field. Splendid .i adore it perusing. buy Ansys
chanyuan (Nov. 24, 2017)
chanyuan2017.11.24

moncler outlet

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren

nfl jerseys wholesale

oakley sunglasses

nhl jerseys

air jordan 4

jordan shoes

kate spade outlet

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

yeezy boost

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

ugg boots clearance

ugg boots clearance

vans shoes

supra shoes

prada shoes

nike shoes

oakley sunglasses

adidas outlet store

ralph lauren pas cher

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren

uggs outlet

cheap nhl jerseys

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

new balance shoes

cartier outlet

louboutin shoes

uggs outlet

burberry outlet

adidas sko

christian louboutin outlet

mulberry bags

michael kors outlet

coach handbags

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses

nba jerseys

true religion jeans

ugg boots

cheap jordans

reebok trainers

ray ban sunglasses

cleveland cavaliers jersey

ugg boots

air max 1

oakley sunglasses

canada goose jackets

true religion jeans

polo ralph lauren

burberry outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

christian louboutin outlet

longchamp outlet

fitflops shoes

oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

nike shoes

canada goose outlet

longchamp solde

canada goose jackets

coach outlet store online

mulberry handbags

uggs outlet

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren

ray ban sunglasses

ugg outlet

moncler outlet

michael kors handbags

ugg outlet

coach outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

cheap snapbacks

polo ralph lauren

fitflops sale clearance

ugg outlet

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet

prada handbags

mulberry bags

ray bans

ray-ban sunglasses

ugg outlet

coach outlet

kicks nice

hermes outlet

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren

adidas shoes

adidas nmd

longchamp handbags

longchamp outlet

coach outlet

true religion jeans

coach factory outlet

chrome hearts

ralph lauren outlet

air max 90

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

jordan shoes

uggs outlet

ralph lauren outlet

ugg outlet

ugg boots

fitflops sale

longchamp handbags

canada goose jackets

kobe shoes

coach outlet

ugg boots clearance

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

canada goose outlet

nike air max 90

longchamp pas cher

michael kors outlet

longchamp solde

hermes outlet

michael kors handbags

prada outlet

canada goose outlet

polo ralph lauren

true religion jeans

cheap jerseys

coach outlet online

ugg outlet

ferragamo shoes

nike outlet

polo outlet

tory burch outlet

kate spade outlet

michael kors

pandora jewelry

coach outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

links of london

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

true religion outlet

oakley sunglasses

ysl outlet

mulberry handbags

kate spade outlet

ferragamo outlet

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet

swarovski outlet

salomon shoes

christian louboutin shoes

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

pandora jewelry

coach outlet

ugg boots

nike outlet

mont blanc pens

mulberry handbags

ugg boots clearance

nike air force 1

canada goose jackets

kate spade outlet

nike outlet

canada goose jackets

giuseppe zanotti outlet

pandora charms

ugg outlet

longchamp pliage

true religion jeans

tory burch outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ugg outlet

jordan shoes

uggs outlet

coach outlet

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet

tory burch outlet

true religion jeans

coach canada

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg boots

uggs outlet

uggs

ray ban sunglasses

tory burch outlet

coach outlet online

ralph lauren polo

michael kors

canada goose jackets

ugg outlet

ray ban sunglasses

kobe bryant shoes

tory burch outlet

ugg outlet

longchamp outlet

thomas sabo

uggs outlet

coach outlet online

swarovski outlet

christian louboutin shoes

ugg outlet

kate spade outlet

coach handbags

oakley sunglasses

fitflops sale clearance

true religion jeans

puma shoes

nike roshe

chicago blackhawks jerseys

hermes belt

longchamp handbags

ugg boots clearance

michael kors outlet online

nike factory outlet

canada goose outlet

christian louboutin outlet

longchamp bags

swarovski outlet

mont blanc pens

fitflops outlet

canada goose outlet

canada goose parka

canada goose black friday

cheap jordans

coach factory outlet

ed hardy clothing

michael kors outlet online

lebron james shoes

tory burch shoes

michael kors handbags

true religion uk

marc jacobs outlet

birkenstock sandals

air huarache

coach factory outlet

ugg outlet

ferragamo outlet

true religion jeans

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet online

pandora jewelry

ralph lauren uk

polo ralph lauren

canada goose outlet

wanglili (Nov. 22, 2017)
fred perry polo ralph lauren uk cheap oakley sunglasses ugg outlet canada goose cheap oakley sunglasses mont blanc pens cheap ugg boots michael kors outlet online nike shoes michael kors outlet store coach outlet canada goose outlet store ugg outlet store michael kors outlet online mulberry outlet lebron james shoes pandora jewelry kate spade outlet store ugg boots clearance oakley sunglasses ugg boots for women adidas shoes ray ban sunglasses fitflop sandals cheap ugg boots nike outlet store coach outlet store online canada goose outlet store canada goose uk michael kors outlet clearance polo ralph lauren coach outlet online coach factory outlet cheap uggs michael kors outlet online cheap jordans for sale adidas yeezy shoes adidas outlet store cheap ugg boots coach factory outlet online coach outlet ray ban sunglasses lacoste shoes clarks outlet coach outlet coach outlet store polo shirts christian louboutin shoes uggs outlet coach outlet canada goose outlet coach outlet online coach factory outlet canada goose uggs outlet canada goose outlet ugg boots nike factory store ralph lauren outlet uggs outlet canada goose outlet online nike air max 90 polo ralph lauren outlet adidas superstar shoes ugg outlet ralph lauren uk canada goose outlet online ralph lauren sale michael kors outlet store uggs on sale coach outlet store online canada goose outlet store ugg outlet fitflops shoes nike outlet store polo outlet oakley sunglasses longchamp outlet ugg boots clearance air jordan shoes canada goose jackets canada goose jackets mlb jerseys wholesale ugg,uggs,uggs canada cheap jordans ugg boots ralph lauren pandora jewelry outlet canada goose jackets michael kors outlet air jordan shoes uggs outlet canada goose outlet oakley sunglasses for men canada goose jackets cheap mlb jerseys ugg outlet online oakley sunglasses canada goose jackets polo outlet michael kors outlet coach outlet uggs outlet canada goose michael kors outlet kate spade outlet canada goose jackets ugg boots clearance canada goose jackets cheap ugg boots canada goose outlet store christian louboutin shoes christian louboutin shoes canada goose outlet supreme outlet polo ralph lauren sale coach outlet online ugg outlet uggs outlet coach outlet online michael kors handbags oakley sunglasses outlet canada goose valentino shoes fred perry outlet canada goose outlet store mulberry bags lacoste shirts michael kors outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet moncler outlet canada goose outlet cheap snapbacks polo ralph lauren true religion ugg outlet polo ralph lauren ugg boots clearance ugg boots canada goose canada goose outlet coach outlet store online ugg boots clearance fred perry polo shirts ferragamo outlet store ugg outlet canada goose canada goose outlet coach outlet store online nike outlet longchamp coach outlet canada goose jackets sale mont blanc pens for sale ralph lauren outlet adidas yeezy michael kors outlet clearance oakley sunglasses wholesale adidas superstar coach factory outlet ray ban polo ralph lauren outlet online polo outlet uggs outlet coach factory outlet coach factory outlet canada goose jackets 20171123WANGLILI

Home | Copyright © 2017, Russian-American Education Forum